Search results
Oct 30, 2013 · In her famous text ‘Patriotism and Cosmopolitanism’, Martha Nussbaum argued for cosmopolitan education in ways that evoked a tension between cosmopolitanism and patriotism. Among others, Charles Taylor considered her treatment of patriotism vague and lopsided, and pointed out that patriotism is not as secondary or as dispensable as Nussbaum ...
- Marianna Papastephanou
- 2013
Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like Nussbaum claims that patriotism is all about ideas and not feelings., Nussbaum presents patriotism as "Janus-faced", meaning that it consists of similar ideas., Nussbaum argues that disgust and shame function as the worst sentiments and more.
Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like Nussbaum claims that patriotism is all about ideas and not feelings., Nussbaum presents patriotism as "Janus-faced", meaning that it consists of similar ideas., Nussbaum argues that disgust and shame function as the worst sentiments. and more.
Among others, Charles Taylor considered her treatment of patriotism vague and lopsided, and pointed out that patriotism is not as secondary or as dispensable as Nussbaum seemed to imply.
Printed in the United Kingdom. Patriotism Is Not Enough. MARGARET CANOVAN* Some political theorists argue that patriotism differs from nationalism in being compatible with universalist liberalism. The theories offered range from the more cosmopolitan constitutional patriotism of Habermas to more rooted republican versions.
Jan 1, 2001 · Nussbaum's initial essay raises an important question: cosmopolitanism or patriotism. She frames the choice in starter terms than needed. Responses by Elaine Scarry, Charles Taylor, Sissela Bok and Robert Pinsky were quite fine.
People also ask
What did Charles Taylor think of Nussbaum's patriotism?
What is Martha Nussbaum's argument against patriotism?
How do writers and thinkers respond to Nussbaum's piece?
Why Democracy Needs Patriotism . Charles Taylor. I agree with so much in Martha Nussbaum's well-argued and moving piece, but I would like to enter one caveat. Nussbaum sometimes seems to be proposing cosmopolitan identity as an alternative to patriotism. If so, then I think this is a mistake.
