Search results
- ‘Taking’ or ‘borrowing’ (without the intent of returning) involves an asymmetry of power between two cultures with the dominant culture taking from the marginalised culture. Appropriation involves taking from a culture that has relatively less power.
frombelow.substack.com/p/cultural-appropriation-what-it-isCultural appropriation: what it is and why it matters - Substack
People also ask
What is cultural appropriation in asymmetrical power relations?
When does cultural appropriation become evident?
Are minority groups cultural appropriation?
Does cultural appropriation matter?
Does cultural appropriation increase inequality and marginalisation?
Is cultural appropriation a contested concept?
Apr 3, 2023 · The literature on cultural appropriation identifies two distinct forms of cultural exchange under conditions of asymmetrical power relations: assimilation and exploitation (Rogers 2006). Assimilation is when members of a less powerful group (e.g., immigrants) use the elements of a more powerful group (e.g., indigenes).
Definition: Asymmetrical power relations encompass situations where power is unevenly distributed among different groups within a society or organisation. This inequality often stems from factors such as race, gender, socioeconomic status, ethnicity, sexual orientation, or ability.
Oct 21, 2023 · Appropriation involves taking from a culture that has relatively less power. ‘Oppression account’ is the taking in this dynamic which increases inequality and marginalisation (Matthes, 2019) – this is what makes appropriation morally wrong.
Cultural appropriation refers to the taking of items (whether tangible or intangible) from one culture by another (Young, 2010, p. 5). To this standard definition, reference to the inequality in power between the two cultures should be included, which problematises the taking.
Key Aspects of Cultural Appropriation. Power Dynamics: Cultural appropriation is inherently linked to power imbalances. The dominant culture often exploits the symbols and practices of marginalised groups without acknowledgment or understanding, leading to feelings of disrespect and exploitation.
Cultural appropriation discourse. Ideological assumptions about power relationships between cultural groups: Aligned with ideology of neoliberal multiculturalism, which occludes power relationships between cultural groups (Veresiu and Giesler 2018)
Jan 1, 2024 · In this paper, we argue that cultural appropriation becomes evident when majority-group members exploit cultural elements from less powerful ethnic groups against their will, often for material or symbolic gains, without providing proper credit or demonstrating a deeper understanding of the culture.
