Search results
Jan 31, 2015 · Abstract. Referring to Kant’s arguments addressing the moral relationship between our bodies and ourselves is quite common in contemporary debate about organ selling, although he does not provide us with any specific arguments related to this debate. It is widely argued that the most promising way to show the moral impermissibility of organ ...
- Zümrüt Alpinar-Şencan
- zumrut.alpinar@ethik.uzh.ch
- 2016
Mar 7, 2008 · Eyal argued that whether the organ trade is repugnant depends, in large part, on the eye of the beholder. “Because we perceive trade in kidneys as incompatible with dignity, a state that carries out trade may causally reinforce the dehumanizing perception,” he said. Kerstein concurred: “Whether selling organs is morally wrong depends in ...
May 30, 2018 · Kant on organ donation. May 30, 2018 ~ philofutures. Elisabeth asked: What would Kant say if keeping a promise or fulfilling a duty, and using oneself as an end, conflicted? For example, someone selling their kidney in order to use the money to buy life-saving surgery for their child? Answer by Paul Fagan. Here we are faced with a conundrum ...
Jan 31, 2015 · Abstract. Referring to Kant's arguments addressing the moral relationship between our bodies and ourselves is quite common in contemporary debate about organ selling, although he does not provide ...
Kass 2002, 185, Morelli 2004, Heubel and Biller-Andorno 2005). Others have argued that any arguments Kant makes against sales also apply to donations, because the arguments are against cutting out and using one’s organs . per se, not just selling them. Some take this to be a reason to forbid both sales and donations,
- D Robert MacDougall
- 2019
tion, Kant is often cited in favour of a prohibition of all organ sales. In her. Nicole Gerrand [1] goes a step further and argues with Kant in favour of a ban on all organ transplantation, on the ground that it is an affront to human dignity. I disagree with her for the following reasons.
People also ask
What does Kant say about organ selling?
Can a Kantian argument be given against Sale of organs?
What are Kant's arguments about organ trade?
Is there a compelling argument against Sale of organs?
What is Kant's concern about giving away body parts or organs?
What does Immanuel Kant say about body?
This paper asks whether it is possible to argue coherently against organ selling in a Kantian framework and it will be shown that by mounting the argument on Kantian grounds no compelling argument can be given against sale of organs. Referring to Kant’s arguments addressing the moral relationship between our bodies and ourselves is quite common in contemporary debate about organ selling ...
