Search results
Fabulous_Version_418. What are some of the most illogical things in Harry Potter universe? Question. In this amazing 7 book long series , what are the things that you find makes no sense or could have been better. For example student need their parent's permission to visit hogsmeade village (safe) but not to enter Triwizard tournament (Dangerous).
- What are the most illogical moments in the series? : r ...
Reply. Liazas. • 9 yr. ago. So many things are illogical:...
- What are the most illogical moments in the series? : r ...
- Staff Writer
- How Werewolves Were Treated. It was quite tragic how werewolves were depicted in Harry Potter. Due to the uncontrolled nature of their transformation, they were treated with contempt and shunned from Wizarding society.
- Love Potions. With Unforgivable Curses and limits to underage magic in place, it was puzzling that Love Potions were made and sold unfettered in Harry Potter.
- The Triwizard Tournament Made No Sense. The majority of Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire revolved around the famous Triwizard Tournament, but it made little sense.
- Kids Were in Charge of Saving the World. Granted, the overused Chosen One trope usually involves kids, but Harry, Hermione, and Ron went through hell to defeat Voldemort.
Aug 18, 2024 · Artem Maltsev. Some ‘Harry Potter’ fans on Ask Reddit have questions about the film. 1. They are able to literally grow bones back from nothing but can’t fix Harry’s eyesight so he doesn’t need glasses. 2. Wizards don’t understand things like phones, muggle clothes, or muggle money. They live in a place where 99% of the population ...
- January Nelson
- The Painting Inconsistency
- How Functional Is The Trace?
- Peter Pettigrew and The Marauders Map
- Harry, Hermione and Ron’s Food Crisis
- Why Didn't The Ministry Use Veritaserum?
- The Magic Behind Thestrals
- Using Multiple Wands
- Why Did The Potters Need A Secret Keeper?
- Why Wouldn’T Voldemort Make The Death Eaters Take The Unbreakable Vow?
- Why Are Legilimency and Obliviate Charms So Readily acceptable?
J.K. Rowling has specifically revealed that the living portraits in the Potter-verse are merely imprints of the dead person. They can imitate their basic personality traits, but do not have feelings, memories and are not as fully realized as ghosts or spirits. But then how is Dumbledore’s portrait able to communicatewisdom and advice to Snape after...
The Trace was a charm that helped the Ministry of Magic know if magic was performed around underage witches or wizards. However, it was revealed eventually that The Trace has its limitations, and while it can detect magic, it cannot detect who performed it. Does that mean underage wizards can get in trouble if someone else uses magic around them, o...
The Marauders Map shows Peter Pettigrew labeled as himself, even when he is in rat form - and Fred and George were constantly checking the map for years. However, neither of them ever saw Peter's name on the map, or that Ron was seemingly sleeping with a 'Peter' every night, despite there being no one by that name in his dorm. And even though Harry...
Through Gamp's Law of Elemental Transfiguration, it is possible to identify what can be conjured and what cannot, and according to the law, one cannot create something from nothing. However, food is one of the five exceptions and Hermione tells Ron that one can summon it if they know where it is, and one can transform it and/or increase the quantit...
Much is made, in the books, of the fact that Lucius Malfoy was suspected as a Death Eater, but never convicted. Like many others, he claimed to be working for Voldemort under the Imperius Curse. However, this seems a little suspicious, as the Ministry could have presumably just used Veritaserum on them to check. It's clear that the Ministry has no ...
This is a problem that J.K. Rowling herself had to demystify, but the fandom just couldn't be appeased. Why couldn’t Harry see the Thestrals at the end of Goblet of Fire, considering he had experienced the loss of Cedric? Thestrals are a breed of skeletal, winged horses that can only be visible to wizards who have ‘seen’ death. Harry was too young ...
This is a problem that has given Redditors many sleepless nights. Harry used three wands and a triple spell to stun Greyback in Deathly Hallows. If a triple spell is more effective based on the simple numerical system of more wands equal more force, why is it not a thing more people use? Plus, it was made abundantly clear in the OWL syllabus that t...
The central tragedy of Harry's life is the betrayal of Lily and James by their friend - which allowed Voldemort to find them. However, the rules of the Fidelius Charm seem to change throughout the series. It's assumed, from the fact that Lily and James has a Secret Keeper, that this was necessary for the charm to work. However, when Bill and Fleur ...
Was Voldemort just too proud or too delusional to think he could trust his Death Eaters? Considering it’s literally a death prophecy he’s trying to negate, shouldn’t he have asked his army of Death Eaters to take the Unbreakable Vow, just to be on the safe side? An Unbreakable Vow works much like a binding magical oath or a contract, it’s enforced ...
The Imperius Curse is an unforgivable curse because it places the victim completely under the caster's control and essentially enslaves their mind. But the mind-reading spell known as Legilimency and the mind-reading charm known as Obliviate are equally dangerous, if not more. The Obliviate spell, especially, can ruin someone’s life, as it can eras...
- List Writer
- Time-Turners Create Huge Plot Holes. The most confusing and nonsensical storyline by far in Harry Potter is the entire concept and usage of Time-Turners.
- The Use Of House-Elves Paints Wizards In A Bad Light. With the exception of Hermione, even the kindest and strongest witches and wizards don't object to the use of house-elves within the Wizarding World.
- The Triwizard Tournament Should Never Have Returned. The Triwizard Tournament in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire is mostly remembered for creating the most awkward romantic relationships and leading to the return of Voldemort.
- Wizards Can Choose Wands Too. Harry's trip to Ollivanders has become one of the series' most iconic scenes. Starting the trend of drawing comparisons between Voldemort and Harry, the wandmaker also delivers one of Harry Potter's most infamous lines: "The wand chooses the wizard."
May 20, 2018 · Most Potter fans were probably expecting someone to draw a wand and try to cast Avada Kedavra before being stopped somehow. That method seems to make the most sense and is definitely the most efficient. MACUSA clearly had a better idea, though, because they created an entire chamber to carry out those sentences.
People also ask
Does Harry Potter make any sense?
Are there any plot holes in Harry Potter?
Why did Harry get trapped under the invisibility cloak?
Do Hogwarts students have Time Turners?
Can divination be taught in a Harry Potter School?
Are Magical Kids homeschooled before Hogwarts?
Reply. Liazas. • 9 yr. ago. So many things are illogical: the overconvoluted triwizard cup gambit, dumbledore "I know or suspect most of the things but it's too risky to share" attitude, the real value of the prophecy, etc. But all these things create a good story so it's everything right at the end.
