Search results
Sheffield has kidnapped Avery, hoping this will lure Toby/Harry out of hiding: “You are his daughter. He will come for you” (321). Sheffield used Mellie to get a piece of Avery’s DNA; Sheffield already had a piece of Toby/Harry’s DNA from the Hawthorne Island fire investigation. He ran a test, and it was a match.
May 7, 2024 · Avery believes the Rooneys could not have Toby, so the group decides to look into the other two families. Avery receives another courier-delivered envelope. It contains a photograph of a beat-up Toby holding a current newspaper. Avery and the Hawthorne brothers find a hidden message in the newspaper in the photo. It says: I always win in the end.
Nov 15, 2021 · While Toby distracts Sheffield, Avery is able to loosen her restraints. Mellie shoots and kills Sheffield. Toby tells Avery although she’s not his biological daughter, he’s always thought of her as his child. He informs her he was there the night Avery was born and he named her. Although Avery begs Toby to stay, he says that he can’t.
In Chapter 14, Grayson said his father, Sheffield Grayson, who had been related to one of the boys killed in the fire, was also not responsible for kidnapping Toby. He believed his father had abandoned his family, but Avery knew that Sheffield was dead. Months earlier, Sheffield had kidnapped Avery to lure Toby out.
Sheffield mistakenly believes that Toby/Harry is Avery’s father; by kidnapping Avery, he hopes to flush Toby/Harry out of hiding and kill him. Sheffield’s motivation is that he wants revenge for the death of his nephew, Colin Anders Wright, who was one of the three teens killed in the Hawthorne Island fire.
Jul 7, 2023 · Avery notices Eve taking photos of one of the files – the one about Grayson’s father, Sheffield. Following up on other clues from the bag, Avery heads to the pool. She uses the glass to discover a mosaic on the bottom of the pool, which is actually a chessboard design.
People also ask
Why does Sheffield kidnap Avery?
Why did Vincent Blake kidnap Avery?
Why does Grayson try to kill Avery?
Did Avery tell Jameson Hawthorne that Toby had a biological daughter?
What happens if Toby loses to Avery?
How does Skye threaten Avery?
One included a gold disk Avery believed was why Toby had been abducted. Another package held a proof of life picture of Toby. A third package contained a cell phone the man used to convey the idea that Toby’s kidnapping was in some way related to the Biblical parable of the prodigal son, an analogy that made no sense to Avery or the Hawthorne brothers.
